Exposed: Mistakes Most Small Businesses Make in Local SEO (And How to Avoid Them)

Home > Blog > local seo > Exposed: Mistakes Most Small Businesses Make in Local SEO (And How to Avoid Them)
Top Local SEO Mistakes Small Businesses Make
January 16, 2023 / By Roger Safont

Local Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is an essential tool for small businesses aiming to attract local customers. However, despite its importance, many companies are unknowingly making costly mistakes. Let’s dive into some of the most common local SEO mistakes and discover ways to sidestep these pitfalls.

Neglecting Google My Business

Common Mistake: Overlooking the Power of GMB

Many small businesses, driven by the rush to get online, hastily set up their GMB listing or neglect it entirely. Such oversight can be detrimental. A properly managed GMB profile helps businesses rank higher in local searches and provides potential customers with essential information at a glance.


For instance, when a resident searches for a service you offer, your GMB listing will show your business hours, location, contact details, and reviews directly on the search results page. An incomplete or incorrect listing can confuse or mislead potential clients.

Comprehensive GMB Management

  • Regular Updates: Like all digital platforms, the information on your GMB should be up-to-date. Regularly review your business hours, especially during holidays or special events, and ensure that any changes in services or products are reflected.
  • Consistency is Key: Your business name, address, and phone number (often referred to as NAP) should be consistent across all online platforms, from your website to social media to directory listings. Inconsistencies can confuse both search engines and customers.
  • Visual Engagement: Photos can significantly enhance your listing. Add high-quality images of your establishment, products, team, or any other relevant visuals that give potential customers a sense of what to expect.
  • Harness the Power of Reviews: Encourage satisfied clients or customers to leave positive feedback on your GMB profile. These reviews serve as testimonials for others considering your services. Moreover, regularly responding to these reviews, both positive and negative, showcases your business’s commitment to customer satisfaction.

Inconsistent NAP (Name, Address, Phone Number) Information

At the core of local SEO is the assurance that potential customers can easily find your business’s essential details—Name, Address, and Phone Number (NAP). The consistency of this data across the web boosts the confidence of potential customers and search engines in displaying your business information.

Common Mistake

Having varying NAP information across different online directories can be detrimental. This inconsistency must be clarified for search engines, leading to a potential loss of credibility and decreased rankings. Imagine the frustration of a potential customer finding two different phone numbers or addresses for your business – which one is correct? This doubt can lead to losing trust, and they might opt for a competitor instead.

The Underlying Problem

Diverse NAP data usually stems from a few sources:

  • Changes in business details over time (e.g., relocating or changing phone numbers) without updating all listings.
  • Manual errors when entering information across different platforms.
  • Relying on third-party data aggregators that might need updated or corrected details.

The Fix

  1. Regular Audits: Set aside time, quarterly or biannually, to review and ensure the consistency of your NAP across all online platforms, including business directories, social media profiles, and your website.
  2. Utilize Online Tools: There are several online tools and services—like Moz Local, Yext, and BrightLocal—that can assist businesses in identifying discrepancies in their listings. These tools scan various directories and platforms to pinpoint where inconsistent or erroneous data exists.
  3. Manual Verification: Sometimes, the old-fashioned way is the best. Regularly check significant platforms, especially those most relevant to your industry, to ensure that your NAP is consistent. Manually updating can seem tedious, but a small effort can yield significant benefits.
  4. Consider a NAP Protocol: Whenever you’re entering or updating business information online, have a standard format or template for your NAP. It ensures that the data remains consistent even if different team members handle listings.

Overlooking Reviews and Ratings

Common Mistake: Ignoring online reviews, both positive and negative.

  • Lost Trust: Potential customers can be deterred by unanswered negative reviews. They might perceive the business as needing to be more accepting of customer concerns.
  • Missed Insights: Reviews can be a goldmine of feedback. Ignoring them means missing valuable insights that could help improve business operations or offerings.
  • Reduced Visibility: Search engines favor businesses that have regular, high-quality, and recent reviews. Ignoring the review process might lead to reduced online visibility.

Engage and Harness the Power of Reviews

  • Encourage Feedback: Actively request reviews from satisfied customers. It could be done post-purchase, after a service is rendered, or even as a gentle nudge in newsletters or receipts. “We’d love to hear your thoughts!” can go a long way.
  • Respond Professionally: Always acknowledge reviews. Thank reviewers for positive feedback, showcasing gratitude, and building rapport. For negative reviews, approach with understanding and professionalism. Address concerns, offer solutions, and, when necessary, take the conversation offline to resolve issues.
  • Implement Feedback: Reviews can provide actionable feedback. If multiple customers point out a similar issue, it might be time to reevaluate certain aspects of your business. Use this feedback to refine and elevate your services or products.
  • Showcase Reviews: Prominently display positive reviews on your website, in marketing materials, or in-store. They act as testimonials, vouching for the quality and reliability of your business.

Keyword Stuffing: When Too Much of a Good Thing Becomes Harmful

Understanding the Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing

Common Mistake: Overloading content with the exact keywords in hopes of ranking higher can result in:

  • Decreased Readability: Too many repetitions can make your content sound unnatural and challenging.
  • Penalties from Search Engines: Google and other search engines penalize sites that employ keyword stuffing because it’s a manipulative practice.
  • Loss of Trust: Readers recognize and are often turned off by content that feels “spammy” or inauthentic.

Crafting Content with Purpose and Relevance

  • Natural Integration: Incorporate keywords organically, ensuring they fit within the context and flow of your content.
  • Focus on Value: Instead of keyword density, provide genuine value to your readers. Answer their questions, address their pain points, and offer actionable insights.
  • Long-tail Keywords: Consider using longer, more specific keyword phrases that can capture a niche audience. Not only are these often less competitive, but they can also be more relevant to a particular group of readers.
  • Synonyms and Variations: Don’t just stick to one version of your keyword. Using synonyms or related terms can make your content more diverse and prevent it from sounding repetitive.

Neglecting Mobile Optimization

Common Mistake

Having a website that isn’t optimized for mobile devices is a significant oversight. With the rise of mobile searches, a business that doesn’t cater to mobile users is missing out on a vast portion of its potential audience. A non-optimized site can lead to frustrated users, increased bounce rates, and a detrimental impact on search rankings.

Google has been clear about the importance of mobile optimization. With its mobile-first indexing approach, it’s evident that sites that provide an excellent mobile experience are given preference in search results. Also, as the digital marketplace becomes more competitive, a user-friendly mobile interface can significantly enhance the chances of converting visitors into customers.

The Fix:

  • Responsive Design: Firstly, businesses must ensure their website is responsive. It ensures that the website adjusts and displays correctly regardless of the device’s screen size, whether a smartphone, tablet, or desktop.
  • Page Load Speed: Slow-loading pages can be a deal-breaker for mobile users. Tools like Google’s PageSpeed Insights can provide insights into what’s slowing down your website and how to rectify it.
  • Simplified Navigation: Mobile screens are smaller, meaning businesses must simplify navigation to ensure a seamless user experience. Dropdown menus, clear call-to-action buttons, and a search option can enhance mobile navigation.
  • Avoid Flash and Pop-ups: Flash isn’t supported on many mobile devices, and pop-ups can be intrusive on smaller screens. It’s best to avoid these elements to enhance the mobile experience.
  • Test Regularly: The mobile digital landscape is continuously evolving. Hence, it’s crucial to regularly test your website on different devices and browsers to ensure compatibility and performance.

Not Utilizing Local Content

Common Mistake

Many small businesses focus their content strategy solely on broad, generic topics that can appeal to a global audience. In doing so, they overlook the immense potential of local-specific content, missing out on an opportunity to engage their immediate community and potential customers.

Why This Is a Problem

Local SEO is all about reaching customers in your vicinity. By failing to produce content that resonates with the local audience, businesses might ignore a significant portion of their target demographic. Locals often search for information, services, and products that are immediately accessible to them. If your content doesn’t reflect local interests and needs, your business could remain invisible to these potential customers.

The Fix

Tailor your content strategy to include topics of local significance. Here’s how:

  1. Local News and Updates: Write articles or create videos about happenings in your town or city that relate to your industry. For example, covering local property market trends can be beneficial if you’re in the real estate business.
  2. Highlight Local Events: Promote or cover local events, mainly if your company participates or sponsors them. It not only helps in local SEO but also boosts community engagement.
  3. Local Guides: Develop comprehensive guides that cater to local interests. For instance, if you run a restaurant, you could compile a list of “Top 10 Dishes to Try in [Your City].”
  4. Engage with Local Influencers: Collaborate with local bloggers or social media personalities to create content. Their local followers can bring more visibility and trust to your business.
  5. Share Customer Stories: Local customers’ testimonials or stories can resonate more with your immediate audience. Highlighting these can prove your credibility and local relevance.
  6. Utilize Local Keywords: In your content, incorporate keywords that locals might use. These can include the names of neighborhoods, landmarks, or popular local spots.